|
Post by Boston Celtics on Jan 22, 2009 19:32:25 GMT
Here are NLSC's most recent rookie ratings. I think we should discuss them here before finalizing them for D5.
Derrick Rose 82 Michael Beasley 82 O.J. Mayo 80 Russell Westbrook 80 Kevin Love 76 Danilo Gallinari 74 Eric Gordon 74 Joe Alexander 74 D.J. Augustin 71 Brook Lopez 69 Jerryd Bayless 74 Jason Thompson 72 Brandon Rush 73 Anthony Randolph 73 Robin Lopez 66 Marreese Speights 66 Roy Hibbert 67 JaVale McGee 67 J.J. Hickson 68 Alexis Ajinca 63 Ryan Anderson 69 Courtney Lee 71 Kosta Koufos 64 Serge Ibaka 60 Nicolas Batum 63 George Hill 67 Darrell Arthur 67 Donte Greene 68 D.J. White 66 J.R. Giddens 68 Nikola Pekovic 59 Walter Sharpe 64 Joey Dorsey 71 Mario Chalmers 71 DeAndre Jordan 65 Omer Asik 57 Luc Mbah a Moute 64 Kyle Weaver 70 Sonny Weems 68 Chris Douglas-Rbts 67 Nathan Jawai 63 Sean Singletary 66 Patrick Ewing 67 Ante Tomic 52 Goran Dragic 67 Trent Plaisted 58 Bill Walker 67 Malik Hairston 65 Richard Hendrix 64 DeVon Hardin 58 Shan Foster 63 Darnell Jackson 58 Tadija Dragicevic 56 Maarty Leunen 62 Mike Taylor 65 Sasha Kaun 52 James Gist 64 Joe Crawford 63 Deron Washington 63 Semih Erden 53 Marc Gasol 70 Rudy Fernandez 73 Othello Hunter 62 Dwayne Mitchell 65 Will Bynum 59 Will Solomon 57 Bobby Brown 60 Anthony Roberson 59 Anthony Tolliver 61 Roko Ukic 64 Marc Gasol 59 David Padgett 53 Sun Yue 63 Anthony Morrow 64
|
|
|
Post by Boston Celtics on Jan 22, 2009 19:35:19 GMT
For some reason Marc Gasol is in there twice.
These are the guys I think should change: Marc Gasol 70, should be 74 Brook Lopez 69 - 78 Brandon Rush 73 - 69
|
|
|
Post by bringit - CHA on Jan 22, 2009 19:57:40 GMT
i think Michael Beasley (82) and O.J Mayo (80) should switch rankings, O.J and Rose have been by far the best rookies this year
|
|
|
Post by Erik Lassen on Jan 22, 2009 20:21:34 GMT
Anthony Morrow deserves higher than a 64 for sure. JaVale McGee and Darrell Arthur could go up too.
My own Geroge Hill deserves at least a 70-73.
|
|
|
Post by Golden State Warriors on Jan 22, 2009 20:32:04 GMT
I think a 73 is a little high for Anthony Randolph, maybe a 70-71. And ever since Elton Brand has been injured Marreese Speights has been averaging 8.2PPG and 4.RPG while having multiple games of 10+ppg and around 8rpg. I could see him at a 70-71
|
|
|
Post by San Antonio Spurs on Jan 22, 2009 21:29:33 GMT
Bayless and Alexander at 74 is pretty high for players who haven't done much IMO
|
|
|
Post by calvinrei - NOH on Jan 23, 2009 12:33:16 GMT
Koufos and Mbah a Moute should also be rated higher than a 64
|
|
|
Post by jlawdrummer - GSW on Feb 1, 2009 5:37:06 GMT
Keep Beasley at an 82. He is just not playing because the coach is being a hardass and trying to make him play/concentrate more on Defense. He leads Rookies in Points per 48 minutes. If he was on a poop team like Memphis, he'd be scoring in bunches like Mayo, but instead he has Wade on his team, and his team is a playoff caliber team.
Mayo - could go up to an 82 though.
Eric Gordon - could go up from 74 to maybe...76-78
Joe Alexander - down to 70ish...he's shown decent skills when he actually gets to play, the Bucks just don't use him much.
D.J. Augustin - could go up a few, maybe 74?
Brook Lopez - big raise needed from a 69...75 or a little higher is good.
Bayless down a couple, he's got talent, just not being used because the Blazers are loaded.
Rush down a couple also...
Anthony Randolph down a point or two i guess...he's been good when he plays, but nellie is a crazy ass coach to play for, and make it hard for us to really evaluate players from his team.
Speights as mentioned, could go up a few points.
McGee and Hickson could both go up a point or two, but i could see leaving them where they are. Same with Ryan Anderson and Courtney Lee...all have shown flashes, but then again haven't done it for very long yet.
Koufos up a couple points, 66-68ish
Batum should probably be 70 IMO. He's started pretty much every game for the Blazers, his numbers are ridiculous, but I think they warrant something around a 70.
George Hill, Darrell Arthur, Donte Greene are all similar to the McGee/Hickson argument...shown flashes maybe, but could fairly stay at those ratings. Just guys to keep an eye on maybe.
DeAndre Jordan fits in here too. I'd say he probably deserves a boost to 68 at least because he looked VERY good when he got time.
Dorsey should come down a couple points...
Chalmers could go up a couple points.
Mbah up a few points
Kyle Weaver down a few points.
Rudy at 73 is fairly good.
Marc Gasol to 70-73 is good.
Anthony Morrow definitely up to at least 68.
|
|
|
Post by Denver Nuggets on Feb 1, 2009 7:12:25 GMT
Jason Thompson at least should be as good as Danilo Gallinari?
|
|